Fourth Week: 31 Des 2007 6 Jun 2008

Google Scholar and Web of Science: Similarities and Differences in Citation Analysis of Scientific Publications

Maurella DELLA SETA, Rosaria Rosanna CAMMARANO

Documentation Service, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Rome, Italy

[e-mail]

Corresponding Author:

Maurella Della Seta

Settore Documentazione, SIDBAE
Istituto Superiore di Sanità
Viale Regina Elena, 299
00161 Roma
Italia
Phone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
Email: [e-mail]  

 My Comment: I leaved for see the cited of special paper in the Web of Science  “cited reference search” must be select and I can’t clic also “cited by” in google scholar.

The autor did your research by good sampling and give very good information in the table and figure form analyses of data.

Reference 9 has writed by Dr. aliReza Nooruzi..

I will need references 8 for read in future. I have reference 7 and 10.

I can connect to Web Of Science websit <http://scientific.thomson.com/webofknowledge/wosgenben.html>

A look at google scholar, pubmed, and scirus: comparsons and recommendations.

Dean Giustini and Eugene Barsky

JCHLA / JABSC 26: 8-89 (2005)

My Comment: That paper have interesting question for GS. We have some search engine that those able to limit by research methodology and publication type but GS and Scirus didn’t have feature!! According by this content.  

Appendex A give me information about CrossRef Search Pilot Project (http://www.crossref.org) but it didn’t enough me.

Examining the Claims of Google Scholar as a Serious Information Source

Bruce White

Science Librarian/Kaitakawaenga Kareti Putaiao

Massey University Library/Te Putanga ki te Ao M tauranga

[e-mail]

My Comment: Roy tannent(2005) dexcribed GS as an “emperor with out clothes”. Jaxo” have been research of for google scholar that I must be read other paper in the next 2007 writhed him. Pages 14 and 13 of paper give me a lot of information abut coverage GS.

Josiah M. Drewry. Google Scholar, Windows Live Academic Search, and Beyond: A

Study of New Tools and Changing Habits in ARL Libraries. A Master’s Paper for the

M.S. in L.S degree. July, 2007. 63 pages. Advisor: Lisa Norberg

 My Comment: Windows Live Academic Search (WLAS)< http://academic.live.com/default.aspx > compare with GS.

I suggestion to read exactly contents in the URL: (see http://scholar.google.com/intl/en/scholar/about.html) (see http://help.live.com).

GS covered papers in the several different databases exiting it very good future for retrieval full text.

How can I create questioners with technology by Qualities. (http://www.qualtrics.com ).